North Carolina’s hog farmers heard the same request for years: cover the lagoons. In 2018, Democratic Rep. Billy Richardson wrote that requiring covers was “the right thing to do,” promising “much needed relief” for the environment and nearby residents.
Many farmers did. Covered digesters now capture methane on dozens of farms, reduce odors and keep rainwater out of lagoons, reducing the risk of overflows. Now some critics blame these same projects for “entrenching” the lagoon-and-sprayfield system.
Apparently, covers were a good idea right up until farmers installed them.
It’s a familiar pattern. Farmers fix one problem, and critics move on to the next.
A record of change
No new hog farms have been built in North Carolina since 1997, when the state imposed a moratorium on new and expanded swine farms. In 2007, the moratorium was made permanent. The state has also permanently closed hundreds of lagoons through voluntary buyout and closure programs.
On existing farms, covered digesters are capturing methane and turning it into renewable natural gas. Projects in Duplin County alone are producing enough renewable energy to serve thousands of homes.
The environmental gains are measurable. A 2023 analysis of anaerobic digestion under North Carolina farm conditions estimated a 90% reduction in methane emissions and a 51% reduction in odor. That is what continued investment in environmental improvements can deliver.
The latest attack
Now, a study published in September claims digesters make ammonia emissions worse.
But take a closer look. The paper includes no new field measurements of its own. Nearly all of its digester data came from a single project in Utah, where manure from 12 farms was piped to a central plant to make methanol.
And here’s an important detail: That Utah study found ammonia emissions were 47% higher than its comparison lagoons. But it suggests increases of three to five times, based on comparisons with other studies conducted in different places under different conditions.
One thing is clear: there are no new measurements of emissions from North Carolina hog farms.
But there is important evidence much closer to home: actual air monitoring in the heart of North Carolina hog country.
The NC Department of Environmental Quality conducted a 17-month air monitoring study in Duplin County. Ammonia was below detection levels for most of the study and never exceeded the state’s acceptable ambient level. DEQ concluded the results “do not constitute a significant air quality issue” in the study area.
That doesn’t mean farmers should stop looking for ways to reduce emissions. It does mean we should put alarming claims in perspective.
There’s no denying that covered lagoons reduce methane and minimize odor. Even this latest study acknowledges that digesters offer important renewable energy and greenhouse-gas benefits.
Improvements are never good enough
Cover lagoons. Close lagoons in flood-prone areas. Capture methane. Reduce odor.
Some critics still say it isn’t enough.
Voltaire put it plainly: “The best is the enemy of the good.” When perfection becomes the standard, every practical improvement gets dismissed.
North Carolina’s hog farmers will keep improving. They’ll keep investing in new technology and looking for better ways to protect our environment.
But at some point, it’s fair to ask what would actually satisfy the critics.
For many, the answer increasingly appears to be nothing short of shutting down hog farms altogether.
The public should recognize these attacks for what they are: an effort to put North Carolina’s pork farmers out of business.